Authored by Michael E. Hartmann via RealClear Wire,
Steve Miller’s December 12 RealClearInvestigations article, “How Tax-Exempt Nonprofits Skirt U.S. Law to Turn Out the Democrat Base in Elections,” is both jarring and informative and helps frame many important questions facing philanthropy, conservatism, and conservative philanthropy.
Miller describes the general size and scope of activities being conducted a progressive nonprofit infrastructure that has “taken on an outsized part of the Democratic Party’s election strategy” and, specifically, how they “work around legal restrictions on nonprofits that accept tax-deductible donations by selectively engaging in nonpartisan efforts including boosting voter education and participation.”
The infrastructure also includes nonprofit grantmaking institutions, which are also tax-advantaged and also evade restrictions on partisan political activity.
As Institute for Free Speech chair Bradley Smith tells Miller, that progressive grant-recipient groups outnumber, outraise, and outspend conservative entities. Contemporary, politicized Big Philanthropy — as my Giving Review co-editor Bill Schambra has noted — is “an oppressively arid, progressive monoculture” and “[c]onservatives need to face this truth.”
On the day Miller’s article appeared, the Subcommittee on Oversight of the House Ways and Means Committee held a hearing on the how the growth of the tax-exempt sector is changing the U.S. political landscape. During the generally non-contentious proceeding, members and witnesses floated or endorsed several potential discrete changes to law and regulations on tax-exemption, foreign funding of exempt nonprofits, and the degree to which those groups and their also-exempt funders can engage in voter registration.
The proposed reforms included, among others, the following: (1) banning foreign contributions to tax-exempt nonprofits; (2) curbing contributions to political super PACs from social-welfare nonprofits that accept foreign contributions; (3) barring private foundations and public charities from funding and engaging in voter-registration projects; (4) banning private contributions to state- and local-government election administration; and (5) redesigning Internal Revenue Service Forms 990, including to request and then provide to the public more information about “fiscally sponsored” projects, and 990-PF.
Two days after Miller’s article and the oversight subcommittee hearing—at the other end of the U.S. Capitol, Sen. J. D. Vance, Republican of Ohio, introduced the College Endowment Accountability Act, which would increase the excise tax on endowment net investment income from 1.4 percent to 35% for secular, private, nonprofit colleges and universities with at least $10 billion in assets under management.
Big Philanthropy is big mostly because of its similarly large nonprofit endowments. Vance’s bold bill would be a decidedly non-incremental policy step, and could serve as an opening bargaining position for future discussions about all such endowments’ tax treatment.
Rates and Rises
The current 1.4-percent tax rate on the endowments of colleges (whose student bodies are majority U.S. citizens, where more than 500 students are tuition-paying, and where total assets exceed $500,000 per student) was set by the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017.
“While it is a relatively small tax, this new law is a first step towards the exploration of taxing non-profit entities on the vast sums of wealth they hold in their endowments,” University of Kentucky law professor Jennifer Bird-Pollan wrote in a Pepperdine Law Review article about the tax and its wider implications.
“If we believe the rationale for imposing the excise tax stems from a distaste for excessive accumulation on the part of these wealthy universities, perhaps we should take the rationale even further,” she observed. “Why are we focused only on universities? … Seeing the 2017 tax bill’s university endowment excise tax as opening the door to imposing tax as an incentive tool to stop the excessive accumulation of wealth by non-profit entities lets us imagine what else we might see ….”
In fact, in the Further Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2020, Congress set the excise tax on the income of private-foundation endowments at a flat 1.39%. Prior to the simplifying change, the rate was 2% percent, but could decrease to one percent if a foundation increased its charitable grant distributions.
Rationales for Reform
If one believes there’s a good rationale for proposing an increase of the tax in the higher-education context, it seems the same rationale would apply to private foundations. Here’s how Vance’s explained his reasoning for a higher-ed endowment tax increase on the Senate floor: “How is it,” he asked, that universities, which “should be responsive to the public will, responsive to their donors and alumni, responsive to their students, how is it that they can go so far so fast without any pushback?”
The answer, he continued, “is university endowments, which have grown incredibly large on the backs of subsidies from the taxpayers, and they have made these universities completely independent of any political, financial, or other pressure ….”
In 2021, prior to formally declaring his Senate candidacy, Vance floated a reform idea that treated the tax status of all nonprofits, including foundations, the same. “[W]e should eliminate all special privileges that exist for our nonprofit and foundation class,” he told a Claremont Institute audience.
Why is it that if you’re spending all your money to teach literal racism to our children in their schools, why do we give you special tax breaks instead of taxing you more? …
The decision to give those foundations and those organizations special privileges is a decision made by public policy. It was made by man, and we can undo it.
Three months later, Vance then specifically applied this equivalence. “Any charitable organization with an endowment over $100 million must spend 20% of its endowment each year, or else it loses its 501c3 status and the preferential treatment of its income,” he proposed. Echoing his made-by-man-and-can-be-unmade thinking, Vance notes, “The Ford Foundation and the Harvard endowment don't have a constitutional right to tax advantages that are unavailable to the vast majority of American citizens.”
Questions
Along with the similar work of others — including at the Capital Research Center, where I’m a senior fellow — Miller’s article, the Ways and Means oversight-subcommittee hearing, and Vance’s bill raise even more fundamental questions. These are especially relevant to conservatism, and conservative philanthropy.
Of philanthropy: What’s it for? If it’s for charity, but it being used for partisan electoral politics, what’s to be done?
Of conservatism: Where on the spectrum of proposed policy reforms, between the carefully tailored oversight subcommittee options and Vance more-existential “threat” to large nonprofit endowments, should principle nudge us? Slight alterations or frontal assaults, or a mixture of both?
Finally, regarding conservative philanthropy: Can it face the truth of how radically progressive, policy-oriented, and partisan most Big Philanthropy has become? Are conservatives bound by principle to defend such a regime? Is the traditional understanding of charity worth somehow trying to preserve despite how the system has been abused by partisan politicization?
Or should the conservative side of philanthropy aggressively “fight fire with fire” and engage in the same kind of politicization itself, if only to try neutralizing the other effort? And if the other side’s fire so often includes successfully influencing the formulation, passage, and implementation of government policy — shouldn’t its fire too?
Michael E. Hartmann is a co-editor of The Giving Review and a senior fellow at the Capital Research Center.
Pingback: fake cialis pictures
Pingback: what does zoloft do to your brain
Pingback: metronidazole suppliers
Pingback: increasing cymbalta dosage from 60 to 90
Pingback: how does lexapro make you feel the first week
Pingback: how long does it take for duloxetine to leave your system
Pingback: can i buy viagra in mexico
Pingback: fluoxetine ocd
Pingback: gabapentin alkoholentzug
Pingback: oral cephalexin
Pingback: keflex side effects elderly
Pingback: escitalopram and propranolol
Pingback: amoxicillin tr k clv
Pingback: porno izle
Pingback: porn
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: porn
Pingback: does cephalexin have sulfa in it
Pingback: ciprofloxacin cost
Pingback: how long does an allergic reaction to bactrim last
Pingback: does bactrim treat mrsa
Pingback: porno izle
Pingback: neurontin and lyrica
Pingback: depakote generics
Pingback: ddavp pregnancy
Pingback: generic version of contrave
Pingback: prozac vs effexor
Pingback: diclofenac for back pain
Pingback: can you take citalopram at night
Pingback: can i take ibuprofen with flexeril
Pingback: cozaar classification
Pingback: flomax water filters
Pingback: diltiazem for afib
Pingback: ezetimibe benefits
Pingback: what is augmentin used to treat?
Pingback: baby aspirin
Pingback: allopurinol classification
Pingback: what are the side effects of aripiprazole
Pingback: how much amitriptyline for sleep
Pingback: nature made ashwagandha
Pingback: can celebrex cause weight gain
Pingback: does augmentin make you tired
Pingback: lambda max of repaglinide
Pingback: not losing weight on semaglutide reddit
Pingback: will robaxin show up on a drug test
Pingback: abilify 5 mg
Pingback: is protonix over the counter
Pingback: actos libres
Pingback: acarbose description
Pingback: how to take remeron
Pingback: porn
Pingback: dhea synthroid
Pingback: tamsulosin dental side effects
Pingback: venlafaxine hydrochloride extended release
Pingback: ivermectin pills human
Pingback: will taking voltaren with extra strength excedrin cause stomach pain
Pingback: spironolactone para que sirve
Pingback: sitagliptin adverse effects
Pingback: tizanidine 2 mg
Pingback: grandpashabet
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: buy brand levitra online
Pingback: pharmacy to fill oxycodone
Pingback: sildenafil for premature ejaculation reviews
Pingback: cialis online pills
Pingback: smiths pharmacy
Pingback: figral sildenafil
Pingback: canadian pharmacy levitra
Pingback: comparison price tadalafil
Pingback: sex historie
Pingback: levitra 10 mg filmtabletten vardenafil
Pingback: sildenafil tablets uk
Pingback: when does tadalafil go generic
Pingback: viagra pharmacy prices
Pingback: stromectol brand
Pingback: stromectol pill price
Pingback: generic tadalafil price
Pingback: cost of ivermectin cream
Pingback: ivermectin 6 tablet
Pingback: ivermectin cream cost
Pingback: vardenafil ed il tadalafil
Pingback: buy stromectol canada
Pingback: animal porn
Pingback: ananın amı
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: augmentin for sinus infection
Pingback: metformin 1000 mg
Pingback: should i take nolvadex while on cycle
Pingback: quinapril to lisinopril conversion
Pingback: how much is amoxicillin
Pingback: can you take gabapentin and lyrica together
Pingback: cephalexin side effects in dogs
Pingback: how long does it take trazodone to work
Pingback: cipro kidney infection
Pingback: does metronidazole cause diarrhea
Pingback: is doxycycline a strong antibiotic
Pingback: provigil canada no prescription
Pingback: how long does it take for keflex to work
Pingback: porn
Pingback: side effects of valtrex for shingles
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: porn
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: sex
Pingback: sex
Pingback: porn
Pingback: sex historie
Pingback: hardcore porn
Pingback: anal porno
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: sex
Pingback: spam
Pingback: porn
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: porn
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: men
Pingback: is rx pharmacy coupons legit
Pingback: levitra for sale online
Pingback: vardenafil availability in us
Pingback: tadalafil vs sildenafil vs vardenafil
Pingback: does sildenafil work
Pingback: tadalafil or sildenafil which is better
Pingback: difference between tadalafil and sildenafil
Pingback: how long does 20mg sildenafil last
Pingback: what is sildenafil 100mg
Pingback: cialis medication
Pingback: buy levitra cialis
Pingback: tadalafil 2.5 mg
Pingback: levitra 60 mg price
Pingback: adipex pharmacy card
Pingback: buy levitra dapoxetine
Pingback: sildenafil vs.tadalafil
Pingback: boots pharmacy viagra
Pingback: buy levitra fast
Pingback: tadalafil 5mg daily how long before it works
Pingback: no prescription online pharmacy
Pingback: what plant does vardenafil originate from
Pingback: birth control pills online pharmacy
Pingback: sildenafil 45 mg reviews
Pingback: what happens if you take expired sildenafil
Pingback: how to flush cialis out of your system
Pingback: finasteride united pharmacy
Pingback: tadalafil 20 mg used for
Pingback: does tadalafil keep you hard after coming
Pingback: tadalafil 20 mg reviews
Pingback: online pharmacy hydrocodone prescription
Pingback: tadalafil how long does it take to work
Pingback: tramadol pharmacy online no prescription
Pingback: vardenafil online pharmacy
Pingback: tricare pharmacy
Pingback: Lanoxin
Pingback: tramadol mexican pharmacy
Pingback: online tadalafil
Pingback: celebrex prescription savings card
Pingback: does neurontin show up in a drug test
Pingback: how long do you wait between motrin and tylenol
Pingback: ketoprofen/gabapentin cream
Pingback: q es celecoxib
Pingback: tegretol long term use
Pingback: sulfasalazine trying conceive
Pingback: ibuprofen or tylenol for infants
Pingback: can i take etodolac with vicodin
Pingback: carbamazepine caffeine interaction
Pingback: imitrex post surgery
Pingback: cilostazol half life
Pingback: can i purchase cheap pyridostigmine pills
Pingback: price of elavil
Pingback: diclofenac sodium topical gel 1 reviews
Pingback: mestinon lp
Pingback: fybogel mebeverine
Pingback: is amitriptyline a controlled substance
Pingback: can you take advil with indomethacin
Pingback: does meloxicam cause back pain
Pingback: contoh manfaat obat piroxicam
Pingback: sumatriptan subcutaneous injection instructions
Pingback: lioresal cvs
Pingback: azathioprine chronic hepatitis
Pingback: can i take motrin and mobic together
Pingback: anemia from imuran
Pingback: baclofen excretion
Pingback: picture of rizatriptan
Pingback: maxalt and pregnant women
Pingback: imdur medication information
Pingback: what is periactin tablets
Pingback: solubility of cyproheptadine hcl
Pingback: artane day care centre
Pingback: where to get cheap ketorolac without rx
Pingback: tizanidine breastfeeding
Pingback: where to get generic toradol pills
Pingback: zanaflex and methocarbamol
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: porn
Pingback: porn
Pingback: porn
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: child porn
Pingback: porn